Hate Crimes

First read this article on a recent hate crime that happened in baltimore
http://www.jewishtimes.com/index.php/jewishtimes/news/jt/local_news/painful_episode/

Maryland Online Hate Crime Resource Center
Requirements for a hate crimeWhen racial, religious or ethnic statements are made during the incident.
When hate group symbols are displayed.
When the motive of a crime is to harm, injure or intimidate a particular group or organization. When the victim perceives it to be a hate crime.

Federal law addresses hate crimes primarily through civil rights statutes and includes the following:

Conspiracy Against Rights - Makes it illegal for two or more people to conspire to injure, threaten or intimidate someone in the exercise of any right provided by the U.S. Constitution.

In addition, federal law provides for increased sentences where a defendant selects a victim because of race, color, religion, national origin, ethnicity, gender, disability or sexual orientation.


In case there was any doubt in your mind that this isn't legally considered a hate crime:

There was a history of anti-Semitic remarks from the students and even though it wasn't recorded that at the moment the noose was presented, one can assume there were such remarks involved which satisfies the first requirement for a hate crime. A noose isn't a symbol of hatred for any specific group; the noose is a symbol for capitol punishment and has been for many centuries. When presented with a noose it is clearly a symbol of hatred, which satisfies requirement number two. When presenting an individual with an international symbol of hate, following countless slanderous comments against him because of religion, one can assume that the cause of the crime was to either intimidate him, scare him, or cause emotional duress, which is fulfills number three. And I am assuming that when the child broke down crying he perceived it as a crime committed towards him out of hatred towards him because of his religion.


Dr. Linkoff. "We were told by our rabbi that it wasn't a hate crime, because there wasn't a Jewish star attached to it, so it can't be anything more than a prank."

I am in no way attempting to disrespect a religious leader but I assure you this is a hate crime.
How many hate symbols does your rabbi require for it to be a hate crime? We have 4 legal markers, and an international symbol of hatred. By the time the child walks into school and there is a noose with a Star of David on it, then I am sorry but you are too late to be able to do anything without drastic legal measures, which would undoubtedly lead to long legal suits and eventually cause more hate crimes from the criminals friends and family instead of preventing them.

The punishment given to the kids was not enough; they stole property from the school to attempt to "frame" the Jewish child. They publicly conveyed a message of hate. And what was the consequence? Missing two days of school…
If I had of known of this secret I would make fun of Jews every day before a test or major assignment. The consequences furthermore did not teach the student body anything, which is shown by one of the criminal's friends attempting to assault the boy with a plastic knife.

These boys are clearly not educated on Judaism and they probably have idiotic misconceptions of what our religion stands for as a whole. And the fact that they can hate a religion which is something that someone believes is a churlish idea. It is impossible to know what is going on in someone's mind. It would be more logical to hate based on what color clothes someone wears then to hate based on belief because at least you can be undeniably sure that your perception of his or her clothes is correct and verifiable. The point is that hatred towards religion is an idiotic idea.

Back to the subject at hand, Missing school in this day and age should not be and acceptable consequence. Punishing uneducated boys by causing them to be less educated is not a logical conclusion anyone should jump to.

They have committed a hate crime in public and have not received their just compensations for it. All that they have received is a little time off and maybe even a little more reason to create more anti-Semitic behavior.